| Name | Total | Name | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Page | 17 | Phoebe | 1 |
| Paine | 7 | Picard | 2 |
| Parker | 3 | Pilou | 1 |
| Parmenter | 39 | Place | 1 |
| Patenaude | 1 | Pomponnelle | 1 |
| Peake | 2 | Porter | 1 |
| Peaslee | 1 | Poulter | 4 |
| Pelletier | 1 | Preston | 15 |
| Pepper | 5 | Provencher | 12 |
| Petit | 2 | Puffer | 2 |
| Petznick | 2 | Purington | 2 |
| Phillipinia | 1 | Pusey | 1 |
| Phillips | 1 | - | - |