| Name | Total | Name | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale | 2 | Smith | 15 |
| Sanderson | 30 | Snow | 11 |
| Sarah | 2 | Sprague | 25 |
| Schenck | 1 | Squire | 1 |
| Schofield | 1 | St Cyr | 1 |
| Seald | 1 | Stahl | 1 |
| Seaver | 1 | Staples | 5 |
| Seiber | 1 | Stauffer | 3 |
| Senecal | 2 | Stearns | 3 |
| Shaffner | 1 | Stephenson | 1 |
| Sharparowe | 1 | Stockwell | 1 |
| Shaw | 2 | Stone | 19 |
| Shepherd | 1 | Stout | 38 |
| Shiley | 9 | Stratton | 10 |
| Shirley | 1 | Streit | 1 |
| Slater | 1 | Strunk | 1 |
| Smeal | 1 | Susannah | 1 |