| Name | Total | Name | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metcalf | 1 | Renaud | 2 |
| Metzger | 1 | Rice | 61 |
| Meunier | 1 | Richard | 1 |
| Mileham | 1 | Richardson | 4 |
| Miller | 1 | Richer | 1 |
| Mitchell | 16 | Riggs | 6 |
| Moodie | 1 | Ritchey | 5 |
| Moore | 1 | Robbins | 10 |
| Moreau | 4 | Rocket | 1 |
| Morin | 10 | Rockwood | 8 |
| Morse | 1 | Rodgers | 2 |
| Moses | 1 | Rolfe | 2 |
| Neate | 1 | Roosa | 1 |
| Needom | 1 | Rose | 2 |
| Nicholl | 2 | Rothotte | 1 |
| Nichols | 1 | Roundy | 1 |
| Norwood | 2 | Ruhlin | 1 |
| Noyes | 1 | Rupp | 7 |
| Orcutt | 1 | Sale | 2 |
| Osborne | 2 | Sandell | 1 |
| Page | 17 | Sanderson | 30 |
| Paine | 23 | Sarah | 2 |
| Parker | 18 | Schenck | 1 |
| Parmenter | 39 | Schofield | 1 |
| Patenaude | 1 | Seald | 1 |
| Peake | 2 | Seaman | 1 |
| Peaslee | 1 | Seaver | 1 |
| Pelletier | 1 | Seiber | 1 |
| Pepper | 5 | Senecal | 2 |
| Petit | 2 | Shaffner | 1 |
| Petznick | 2 | Sharparowe | 1 |
| Phillipinia | 1 | Shaw | 3 |
| Phillips | 1 | Shepherd | 1 |
| Phoebe | 1 | Shiley | 9 |
| Picard | 2 | Shirley | 1 |
| Pilou | 1 | Slater | 1 |
| Place | 1 | Smeal | 1 |
| Pomponnelle | 1 | Smith | 15 |
| Porter | 1 | Snow | 11 |
| Poulter | 4 | Sprague | 25 |
| Preston | 15 | Squire | 1 |
| Provencher | 12 | St Cyr | 1 |
| Puffer | 2 | Stahl | 1 |
| Purington | 2 | Staples | 5 |
| Pusey | 1 | Stauffer | 3 |
| Ranck | 11 | Stearns | 3 |
| Rank | 1 | Stephenson | 1 |
| Raynsford | 1 | Stockwell | 1 |
| Redman | 1 | Stone | 19 |
| Reilly | 3 | Stout | 38 |